Diagnostic accuracy of the BD MAX MDR-TB assay on sputum and tongue swabs for <i>Mycobacterium tuberculosis</i> complex detection in adults under investigation for TB in South Africa
Anura David, Lyndel Singh, Manuel Pedro da Silva, Keneilwe Peloakgosi-Shikwambani, Zanele Nsingwane, Violet Molepo, Wendy Stevens, Lesley Scott
Microbiology Spectrum · 2025-11
Abstract
complex (MTBC) and resistance to rifampicin (RIF) and isoniazid (INH), but data on clinical performance are limited. This study assessed the assay's performance on sputum and tongue swabs (TSs). The assay was evaluated for MTBC detection and RIF and INH resistance profiling on sputum using liquid culture as the reference and Xpert MTB/RIF Ultra (Ultra) as a comparator. Diagnostic accuracy for MTBC detection on TS was also assessed. Among 335 participants (56% HIV prevalence), MAX MDR-TB on raw sputum showed an overall sensitivity and specificity of 88.7% (95% confidence interval [CI]: 78.1-95.3) and 98.2% (95% CI: 95.8-99.4) compared with culture and strong agreement with Ultra (Cohen's kappa = 0.853). A total of 15/55 (27%) sputum samples were classified as "MTB low POS." Two false RIF-resistant results were observed. INH resistance was missed in two cases. Although specimen numbers were small, TS demonstrated better diagnostic accuracy when using a diluted sample treatment reagent (STR) (66%) buffer. Although the MAX MDR-TB assay demonstrated good agreement with Ultra, Ultra identified more TB cases. Preliminary findings suggest that TS, particularly with a diluted STR buffer, may be a feasible specimen type, but larger studies are required. The high frequency of MTB low POS results highlights the importance of technology assessment by TB programs prior to implementation to minimize repeat testing and enhance diagnostic reliability. IMPORTANCE: complex using sputum and tongue swabs from individuals being assessed for tuberculosis (TB) in South Africa. Rapid and reliable TB diagnosis is crucial for early treatment and preventing transmission. The MAX Multi Drug Resistant Tuberculosis (MAX MDR-TB) assay is a fully automated molecular test that can simultaneously detect TB and drug resistance, offering a potentially faster and more efficient alternative for TB diagnosis. By assessing its performance on different specimen types, this study provides valuable insights into its reliability in clinical settings. Although the MAX MDR-TB assay demonstrated strong agreement with the Xpert MTB/RIF Ultra assay, it identified fewer TB cases. Tongue swabs were also shown to be a feasible specimen type for testing. This research contributes to global TB control efforts by evaluating advanced diagnostics that could streamline testing, reduce delays, and ultimately improve patient outcomes.
MeSH terms
- Sputum
- Medicine
- Diagnostic accuracy
- Tuberculosis
- Tongue
- Tuberculosis diagnosis
- Reliability (semiconductor)
- Diagnostic test
- Mycobacterium tuberculosis
- Internal medicine
- Pathology
- Clinical diagnosis