TB Research

Private Practitioner Characteristics and Their Potential to Contribute to Tuberculosis Management in Indonesia

Bachti Alisjahbana, Budi Sujatmiko, Nur Afifah, Nury Fitria Dewi, Bony Wiem Lestari, Panji Fortuna Hadisoemarto, Susan McAllister, Philip C. Hill

Research Square · 2023-12

Abstract

Abstract Background Many tuberculosis (TB) patients first seek care through the private health sector; however, most private practitioners (PPs) are not linked to the National TB Program (NTP). We aimed to map, characterize, and assess the potential contribution of PPs to the Indonesian NTP, particularly for TB diagnosis and care. Methods This study was conducted between August 2017 and April 2018 in Bandung city, West Java, Indonesia. Trained enumerators surveyed 30 (of 73) randomly selected community health centers (CHCs) to identify the location of private health care facilities (HCFs) and recorded service characteristics, including physician’s qualifications and practice schedules. We also asked whether the PPs were managing patients with respiratory tract infection (RTI), ordering a TB diagnosis in the past three months, or treating TB patients at the time of interview. Results Among the 936 practicing PPs, 27 (IQR: 12–40) were distributed widely per CHC area. We successfully interviewed 674 (72.0%) PPs, 88.1% (594/674) of whom reported managing patients with RTI symptoms. Most PPs were administered in clinics with multiple providers (78.6%; 530/674), and 21.4% (n = 144) of the PPs were administered in a single-provider clinic. A small proportion of PPs practiced in HCFs were equipped with an X-ray (10.1%) or laboratory (27.1%) facility, and 23.2% collaborated with the national health insurance system. Almost three-quarters (70.0%) practiced in an HCF with a pharmacy. A third (33.3%; 209/627) provided services after weekday office hours, and 28.3% (191/674) offered weekday and weekend clinics. Of the PPs managing RTI patients, 241 (40.6%) reported encountering TB patients, and 101 (17.0%) had TB patients under their treatment program at the time of the interview. Overall, they self-reported that 937 patients were diagnosed with TB in the past three months and that 354 TB patients were receiving treatment. Conclusions PPs have great potential to contribute to TB care because they are present in large numbers, are well distributed in all CHC areas, and can provide services after regular office hours. Some PPs even worked in HCFs supported by X-rays, laboratories, and pharmacies. We should seek ways to engage PPs optimally with the NTP.

MeSH terms

  • Medicine
  • Family medicine
  • Pharmacy
  • Tuberculosis
  • Indonesian
  • Health care
  • Private sector
  • Private practice
  • Health facility
  • Environmental health