The mortality predictive model for tuberculosis patients in Malaysia: an application of surveillance data 2013–2014
Nurhuda Ismail, K. Kartini, A. Abd-Razak, R. Asmah, F.D. Jiloris, I. Ahmad Izuanuddin
International Journal of Infectious Diseases · 2019-01
Abstract
Purpose: Mortality due to tuberculosis (TB) remained a challenge in Malaysia. Its mortality burden has been persistent and the highest among all notifiable infectious diseases for the last thirty years. We made use of the nationwide TB surveillance data to develop a mortality predictive model for TB patients managed in Malaysia. Methods & Materials: A content analytic exercise was conducted by using a two-year notification data in 2013 and 2014. The dataset was processed and the characteristics of mortality were explored. Results: Out of 48,780 notified TB cases, there was 6.01% mortality cases whereby 32.82% (n = 931) had died directly due to TB. The mean age was 50.84 (SD = 18.67) years old, male (69.1%), Malaysian (88.5%), Malay (46.5%), with low education (95.1%) and without permanent income (65%), non-diabetic (81.5%), non-smoker (62.9%) and without HIV co-infection (88.1%). The majority of cases were new cases (90.9%), pulmonary smear positive (70.7%) and with BCG scars (71.4%) who died during the first two months of intensive treatment phase (87.8%). Further analysis revealed that age, late presentation, pulmonary severity, presence of secondary infection and meningitis were significant predictors of mortality for TB patients in Malaysia [p < 0.05]. The risk of mortality significantly increased with late presentation, worsening of pulmonary severity, presence of meningitis and secondary infection respectively [Adjusted OR 95%CI: 16.078% (11.796%-21.913%); 2.022% (1.682%-2.431%); 1.634% (1.101%-2.426%); 1.46% (1.182%-1.792%) respectively]. Age was also found to be a significant predictor, however, at a small and low risk of 2.4% with increase in age [Adjusted OR 95%CI: 0.986% (0.981%-0.991%)]. Conclusion: This is a significant TB mortality model that represented TB patients managed in Malaysia with strong predictive probability [95%CI: ROC AUC 73.6% (71.5%; 75.7%); Hosmer and Lemeshow chi-squared = 7.313 (p > 0.503)]. Further work on risk scoring and characterization of TB mortality is warranted to develop a predictive mortality checklist tool for early and targeted interventions. Further analyses on mortality according to high risk subpopulations such as TB-diabetes, TB-elderly and TB-healthcare workers are also highly recommended for in-depth understanding to formulate and implement subpopulation-targeted interventions.
MeSH terms
- Medicine
- Tuberculosis
- Internal medicine
- Pulmonary tuberculosis
- Malay
- Pediatrics